Renewal by Andersen vs. Marvin Windows: How To Choose Your Window Replacement Company

What is the first step in choosing a window replacement company?

Focus on what matters most to you.

Are you looking to replace old or broken windows?
Would you like to brighten a dark or dull living space?
Do you want a window that helps reduce energy costs?
Are you simply looking to add beauty to your home?

When beginning your window replacement project, you should understand that not every window replacement company is a good fit for your needs. Some elements of top industry brands like Renewal by Andersen and Marvin Windows can significantly influence your decision-making process. Let’s find the best window replacement company for you today!

What If I Just Want Pretty Windows?

When it comes to enhancing your home, the desire for “just pretty windows” is completely valid and achievable. Marvin Windows offers beauty and functionality with various window styles. Marvin’s customization options also include various window frame materials, like wood, aluminum, and fiberglass.

On the other hand, Renewal by Andersen stands out for its extensive customization options that complement a variety of preferences and design needs of homeowners. With this process, you can choose the best colors to complement the interior and exterior of your home.

The customization options don’t end with color. Renewal by Andersen also offers a variety of hardware styles and finishes. Additionally, grille designs are available in several patterns, providing an opportunity to enhance the architectural style of the home or add character to the windows.

This dedication to offering personalized options ensures that every window installation is unique, reflecting the homeowner’s vision down to the last detail.

What If I Want Durable Windows?

For the average consumer, durability is the key to determining the value of any product or service. When it comes to window replacements specifically, durability becomes a top concern for homeowners.

Renewal by Andersen Fibrex® Material

Renewal by Andersen’s durable windows include Fibrex® material, an Andersen-exclusive composite engineered for longevity, thermal insulation, and structural integrity. Fibrex® material comprises 40% reclaimed wood fiber by weight, combined with thermoplastic polymer to produce eco-friendly, durable window frames.

Fibrex® material is twice as strong and lasts twice as long as vinyl. The strength of Fibrex® allows for slimmer frames, which translates to more glass area and better views. The material’s superior insulating properties help in reducing heat transfer, keeping your home comfortable in every season while potentially lowering energy costs.

Renewal by Andersen’s windows are designed with performance in mind. Unlike traditional materials, Fibrex® material does not warp, crack, or corrode over time. Its resistance to fading, blistering, and peeling under extreme weather conditions or fluctuating temperatures. After two decades of testing in Minnesota’s climate, this composite material is proven to perform just as well as the day it was installed.

Marvin Windows Material

With Marvin Windows, you can choose the replacement window collection that best aligns with the material you want. Determining the right window frame material is based on factors like budget, climate, performance, and energy efficiency, Here are the materials that Marvin Windows offers:

Wood: Many homeowners may choose wood for their window frames because of its insulation and natural beauty. Ideal for traditional and historic homes, wood frames can be painted or stained to match any décor for versatility in design. However, wood requires regular maintenance to keep looking and performing well through the years.

Extruded Aluminum: For a modern look with durability, Marvin Windows offers extruded aluminum-clad windows. This option gives homeowners aluminum frames on the exterior and wood frames on the interior. The aluminum exterior has design finishes that resist fading and chalking. Unfortunately, aluminum frames have poor heat transfer, which means your heating and cooling systems will work harder during extreme seasons.
Fiberglass: Fiberglass is one of the best window frame materials for strength and durability. Although less than other materials like vinyl, fiberglass does expand and contract with temperature changes, which could potentially affect the seal and performance of the window over time.

Homeowners appreciate Marvin’s variety in window frame materials. These options allow homeowners to choose the perfect match for their home’s style and their personal preferences.

What If I Want Energy-Efficient Windows?

You may experience harsh winters or scorching summers where you live. In that case, Replacing your current windows with energy-efficient windows can be a lifestyle and financial game-changer.

The ENERGY STAR® Certification

When navigating the choices for energy-efficient windows, the ENERGY STAR® logo establishes trust in the window’s performance. Both Marvin and Renewal by Andersen proudly offer ENERGY STAR® certified windows, aligning with stringent energy performance standards set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Replacing old windows with these certified products can lower household energy bills by an average of 13% nationwide 12% nationwide —a testament to the tangible benefits of making the switch.

Marvin Windows

Marvin’s focus is on multi-pane glass and coatings. By integrating tripane glazing, Marvin’s windows provide insulation, reducing heat transfer year-round. The role of low-emissivity (low-E) coatings keeps your home’s temperature more consistent but also protects your interior spaces from the sun’s damaging rays without diminishing natural light.

Renewal by Andersen

Renewal by Andersen distinguishes itself with its High-Performance™ Low-E4® glass, demonstrating the company’s commitment to energy efficiency. This innovative glass option is designed to minimize heat transfer, significantly enhancing the insulative properties of their windows. For homeowners with specific energy-saving goals, Renewal by Andersen offers a range of custom glass options, designed for extreme weather conditions or optimized for solar heat gain.

Beyond the glass itself, a window’s performance is tied to the quality of its installation. Renewal by Andersen improves the window replacement experience with professional installation methods developed over years of service. Certified Master Installers replace each window with a precision that guarantees airtight seals and proper weatherstripping. This careful attention to installation details prevents air and moisture leaks, further contributing to energy savings and the overall efficiency of your home.

What If I Want The Best Warranty & Value?

So many homeowners are asking “Which window replacement company has the best warranty?” That’s because they recognize the additional value that future coverage and protection bring to their investment. It’s not just about the quality of the windows at the time of installation but also about how they perform and are supported years down the line.

Industry Standard Warranty

Most warranties in the window replacement industry will cover glass or materials when damaged but rarely cover the labor costs that come with the replacement. Marvin Windows offers a variety of limited warranties based on the collection you may choose. Here’s a breakdown of key aspects typically covered in Marvin’s warranty:

Materials and Workmanship: Marvin often warrants that their windows and doors will be free from defects in materials and workmanship. This includes the window frame, glass, and any moving parts such as locks and handles.
Glass: The warranty usually includes coverage for glass components, protecting against issues like seal failures, which can lead to fogging between panes. Marvin’s use of high-quality glass also means enhanced durability against cracking or breakage under normal use.
Finish: For windows that feature a cladded exterior, Marvin typically provides a warranty against chipping, peeling, cracking, or fading of the finish over a specified period. This ensures that the aesthetic appeal of your windows remains intact.

Homeowners need to review the specific warranty documentation provided at the time of purchase, as terms and coverage details can vary by product line and installation requirements. Marvin’s approach to warranty coverage underscores their confidence in the quality and durability of their products, aiming to ensure that homeowners enjoy their windows and doors for many years to come.

While Marvin offers a strong limited warranty, the mixed reviews regarding their customer service highlight the importance of considering the entire customer experience in your decision-making process for value.

The Nation’s Best Warranty

Renewal by Andersen offers one of the most compelling warranty packages in the window replacement industry, reflecting their confidence in the durability, performance, and longevity of their products. Called the nation’s best warranty coverage, it is the only warranty among top-selling window companies that meets all of the following requirements:

easy-to-understand terms
unrestricted transferability
installation coverage
labor coverage
geographically unrestricted
coverage for exterior color
insect screens and hardware
no maintenance requirement

Enjoy up to 20 years of protection for your replacement window’s glass and Fibrex® material with up to 10 years of coverage to replace hardware and other non-glass components.

Beyond the Warranty: Unmatched Customer Care

What sets Renewal by Andersen further apart is not just the duration and coverage of their warranty but also the company’s commitment to responsive and effective customer service. Recognizing that a warranty is only as good as the support that backs it, Renewal by Andersen provides homeowners with full access to prompt, courteous, and professional service whenever they need it. This commitment to post-installation support addresses common concerns homeowners might have about maintaining the performance and look of their windows over time.

What If I Want Durable, Energy-Efficient Replacement Windows?

If you’re looking for a full-service window replacement service that provides durable, energy-efficient replacement windows, choose Renewal by Andersen today. With a commitment to building made-to-order replacement windows, Renewal by Andersen ensures not only a perfect fit for your home’s style but also a promise of lasting performance and enhanced energy conservation.

How Does Renewal by Andersen Work?

The full-service approach to upgrading your windows is centered around the Renewal by Andersen® Signature Service. This service includes the best people in the industry, a superior process, and an exclusive product. Renewal by Andersen offer a comprehensive, start-to-finish process designed to make your window replacement experience as efficient and satisfying as possible in four easy stages.

Personalized Consultation: Your window replacement begins with a personalized consultation to understand your needs, preferences, and the unique characteristics of your home. Expert design consultants work closely with you to craft the perfect window solution that aligns with your vision.
Custom Manufacturing: Each window is custom-made to ensure a precise fit and optimal performance. Utilizing the exclusive Fibrex® composite material and High-Performance™ Low-E4® glass, Renewal by Anderse guarantee windows that are not only beautiful but also exceptionally energy-efficient and durable.
Professional Installation: Certified Master Installers take over to ensure your windows are installed with meticulous care and precision. This step is crucial for maximizing the lifespan and efficacy of your windows, ensuring they perform as intended, reducing energy costs, and enhancing your home’s comfort.
Warranty and Support: Completing Renewal by Andersen® Signature Service is the peace of mind that comes with their industry-leading warranty, covering glass, frames, and installation, ensuring your investment is protected.

Is Renewal by Andersen Worth It?

The overall value of the full-service process, the expertise of a team of experts, and the warranty.

Investing in Renewal by Andersen windows transcends the mere act of purchasing new windows; it’s an investment in a worry-free experience that brings lasting value to your home. Here’s why choosing Renewal by Andersen is worth it:

Unmatched Quality and Durability: With Fibrex® material and energy-efficient glass options, you’re choosing windows designed to last, reducing the need for future replacements and repairs.
Customized Solutions: The focus on custom manufacturing means your windows will be uniquely yours, tailored to meet your specific design and performance needs.
Energy Savings: The energy efficiency of Renewal by Andersen® replacement windows not only contributes to a more comfortable living environment but also noticeable savings on energy bills, making them a smart choice for the eco-conscious homeowner.
Expert Installation: The expertise of the installation team cannot be overstated. Proper installation is key to the longevity and performance of your windows, and these professionals ensure this is done right the first time.
Comprehensive Warranty: A robust warranty reinforces the confidence homeowners have in Renewal by Andersen, offering you peace of mind in your investment.

Choosing Renewal by Andersen for your custom replacement windows means entrusting your home to experts who care deeply about bringing your vision to life, with the assurance of durability, energy efficiency, and unmatched customer service. It’s not just about windows—it’s about creating better ways of living.

Which Window Replacement Company Is The Best?

Deciding between Marvin Windows and Renewal by Andersen comes down to aligning their offerings with your home renovation goals. If your heart is set on pretty windows and some improved energy efficiency, Marvin Windows might work for you.

However, if you value durable, energy-efficient custom replacement windows and a personalized service experience, Renewal by Andersen is the best option for you! Your home reflects your life’s story. Choose the windows that will best tell that story to the world, and bring you comfort, beauty, and efficiency for years to come.

Contact Renewal by Andersen near you today to schedule your free, in-home design consultation with professionals.